RoadBeer - Brewery Finder and Trip Planner
← Back to Search

Old Tappan Brewing Company

Brewery in Bayville, NY

Old Tappan Brewing Company logo
5.8

RoadBeer Score

Our custom score balancing beer quality, vibe, and logistics

1,491 total ratings

Top Beers (20)

Pumpkin Stout

Stout - Other

5.8% ABV 22 ratings
Login
7.9/10

Pumpkin Ale

Pumpkin / Yam Beer

5.3% ABV 21 ratings
Login
7.9/10

Little Spoon's Milk Stout

Stout - Milk / Sweet

5.5% ABV 30 ratings
Login
7.7/10

Aggie's Freak-Out Oatmeal Stout

Stout - Oatmeal

5.5% ABV 40 ratings
Login
7.6/10

Hopped Tropic

IPA - American

7.0% ABV 38 ratings
Login
7.5/10

Yule Spiced Red

Winter Ale

6.3% ABV 17 ratings
Login
7.5/10

Wild Lines Session IPA

IPA - Session

3.8% ABV 66 ratings
Login
7.4/10

OldTappantoberfest

Märzen

5.5% ABV 32 ratings
Login
7.4/10

Hopped Red Ale

Red Ale - Other

4.0% ABV 31 ratings
Login
7.4/10

Pine Island IPA

IPA - American

7.0% ABV 21 ratings
Login
7.4/10

Bog Monster

IPA - New England / Hazy

5.5% ABV 89 ratings
Login
7.3/10

English Mild

Mild - Other

3.7% ABV 98 ratings
Login
7.3/10

Irish Red Ale

Red Ale - Irish

5.5% ABV 44 ratings
Login
7.3/10

Bayville Blonde Ale

Blonde / Golden Ale - Other

5.0% ABV 162 ratings
Login
7.2/10

Blueberry Ale

Pale Ale - American

5.5% ABV 94 ratings
Login
7.2/10

Accidents Will Hefe'n

Wheat Beer - Hefeweizen

4.2% ABV 79 ratings
Login
7.2/10

Northeast Kingdom Maple Brown Ale

Brown Ale - American

7.0% ABV 19 ratings
Login
7.1/10

Bionic Osprey

IPA - American

7.2% ABV 173 ratings
Login
7.0/10

NY Cream Ale

Cream Ale

5.4% ABV 76 ratings
Login
7.0/10

Bionic Osprey

IPA - American

7.2% ABV 173 ratings
Login
7.0/10

Location

Address
37 Ludlam Ave
City, State
Bayville, NY

Actions

Add to Trip Visit Website Get Directions

Beer Selection

58
Beers Available